Thoughts for
Catholics impacted by the Boy Scouts of America membership policies
Two groups of Catholics are
directly impacted by the decision of the Boy Scouts of America to not prohibit youth
members who profess a same-sex orientation, namely, Catholic sponsoring
organizations and Catholic scouts and their families. Please remember, as you read this, I write
this with the approval of my bishop, and as Diocese of Phoenix Boy Scout
Chaplain.
The Church teaches that of
homosexual acts are objectively “disordered.”
Second, the Church calls on persons who experience same-sex attraction
“to fulfill God’s will in their lives” and to practice chastity which is the
same for them as for all unmarried persons.
Third, the Church warns society to avoid “every sign of unjust
discrimination” against those who experience same-sex attraction.
The policy adopted by the Boy
Scouts states: “No youth may be denied membership in the Boy Scouts of America
on the basis of sexual orientation or preference alone.”
The policy applies only to youth
members (aged 11 thru 17), not to adult leaders who, per the Supreme Court
decision in Boy Scouts v. Dale in 2000 are excluded based a private
organization’s right to set its own standards for membership. The new policy applies only to membership in
the Boy Scouts. There are some details
of participation in certain activities that still need to be addressed.
There is nothing in the new policy
or in Boy Scout literature that endorses or advocates the gay life style; in
fact all members are prohibited from using the Boy Scouts to promote “any
social or political position or agenda”.
The non-discrimination principle is
outlined in Catechism of the Catholic Church #2358. If the principle means anything, it means
that the burden of proof lies on those who would discriminate against persons
experiencing same-sex attraction to justify that discrimination. Discrimination (e.g., refusing to recognize
“same-sex marriage”) can and should be defended among Catholics.
That same-sex attraction itself (which
is the only factor addressed by the BSA policy) should bar membership in a
secular organization seems difficult to argue; to propose further that
maintaining such a bar is a litmus test for Catholic sponsorship of an
organization is even less sound.
Consider this: same-sex attraction,
standing alone, does not prohibit one from being a fully initiated Catholic. To argue, therefore, that, a Catholic parish
must hold a sponsored organization to a higher membership standard than it
holds itself to is inconsistent.
An official statement accompanying
the new policy “reinforces that Scouting is a youth program, and any sexual
conduct, whether heterosexual or homosexual, by youth of Scouting age is
contrary to the virtues of Scouting.” Such a statement seems totally in-line with
sound Catholic teaching against sexual activity outside of marriage and stands
in contrast to the indifference toward premarital sex shown by some other youth
organizations let alone to some group’s partnering with organizations like Planned
Parenthood.
Indeed, aside from youth programs
expressly oriented toward chastity, I know of no other secular organization
that so clearly declares all sexual conduct by its youth members to be contrary
to its values as does the Boy Scouts of America.
This is enough to relieve Catholic
organizations from concerns that their sponsorship of the Boy Scouts is
incompatible with Church teaching on human sexuality. Whether Catholic organizations or individuals
may dissociate themselves from Boy Scouts without fear of giving bad example to
others is another question. There is no
obligation to sponsor or join Boy Scouts in the first place. My 50 plus years of experience in Scouting was
and continues to be a healthy and entirely “sex-free” adventure.
Scouting requires serious
commitments of time, talent, and treasure. If Catholic sponsoring organizations and/or
member families can’t agree that the Boy Scouts are able to deliver a youth
program that actually operates within the parameters expressly asserted by the
Boy Scouts, then they will likely decide that the challenges of Boy Scout
affiliation exceed the benefits. I argue
otherwise.
But, unless and until another conclusion
is demonstrated on evidence and not largely on predictions or fears, I think that
Catholics may, and should, take the Boy Scouts at their word and continue to
enjoy the programs offered.
This new standard more closely
aligns with Catholic Church teaching. Some
had actually been concerned about the old standard for some time, because we
have no other youth organizations in the diocese that would exclude youth
struggling with same-sex attraction. We
don't kick them out of our Catholic
High Schools, Parish
Youth Groups, or even our sports teams. We
just challenge all unmarried persons of any age to live a life of
chastity. We have our work cut out for
us to hit this challenge head on, but if we are successful it will "bear
good fruit."
When people have spoken to me about
the change, I simply ask three simple questions. The practical question is "where do you
send your kid to school? Do you realize
that your child’s school would not kick out a young man who claims same-sex
attraction?"
The second question is more
theological. "Which children should
we throw away? Don't all of God's
children deserve the Christian values of Scouting or do only those who are 'morally
straight' in our eyes deserve this experience? Is it our right to chose who is deserving of
Scouting's values or does God hold that in His hands?"
The third question asks them for an
honest reflection. Will this policy make
being a Scout leader more difficult? Perhaps,
but isn't helping all of God's children our ministry? Does it make me uncomfortable? It may, but our job is to figure it out so
every kid has a chance.
Jesus said "Feed my
lambs." He didn't say anything
about the lambs themselves, only that they needed to be fed. So it is with us and the Scouts, Scout
Leaders, Parents, and even the Parish Leaderships that we care for. They need to be fed by good shepherds that set
good examples and display moral discipline in the face of an otherwise amoral
society. The sun will come up; the BSA
and the Catholic Church will still be around, and then it'll be time for calmer
heads to prevail.
Scouts and parents of this country
need us and they need the Scouting movement, especially in light of the
ever-increasing lapse of morals in America. Since they need us, let's keep meeting their
needs.
What a wonderful opportunity that
has been handed to us at this moment in the history of the Church to broadcast
what the Catholic Church teaches on sexuality in general, and homosexuality in
particular. How often do we get people
calling wondering what the Catholic Church teaches? If we approach this moment in the spirit of
the New Evangelization I'm confident we'll come up with communications that not
only allay fears, but will convey the Good News of Jesus Christ.
Our mission with the BSA remains
unchanged. Our God is much larger than
all of this. He is in control, and will
make something great out of this to glorify Him ~ as He usually does.